All Activity
- Past hour
-
Post Skywalker Saga Star Wars Movies
Seto Kaiba replied to jvmacross's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
Maybe... but, then again, we're talking about a clash of flavors there. Andor's brand of grounded, realistic, and mature storytelling with its focus on moral ambiguity and the struggles of regular people won't mesh well with the more fantastical style and larger-than-life characters and caricatures used in more conventional Star Wars media. Consider, if you will, that LucasFilm intended The Force Awakens to be a literal and maximally accessible fresh start for Star Wars rather than a simple sequel. The film being a de facto soft reboot of Star Wars was in aid of that goal. It was meant to be appealing and accessible to a new generation of viewers who may not have seen any of Star Wars before or at least may not have found their parents and grandparents old movies all that interesting. Hiring J.J. Abrams to helm it surely sounded like good business in the abstract since he was a rising star who had recently done a soft reboot of another major sci-fi franchise... even if they apparently missed that his attempt at a soft reboot of the Star Trek franchise was widely panned by fans and underperformed at the box office. The mess that ensued after the first movie's lukewarm reception was partly down to J.J. Abrams's tendency to save all the reveals and explanations for the third act (acceptable in a single film, but a terrible idea in a trilogy) and partly because the studio saw all of the social media hot takes and generally mediocre audience response, panicked, and overcorrected in the next movie instead of sticking to what they'd planned out. Disaster ensued. Yeah, that's not happening. Disney LucasFilm's not going to broom the sequel trilogy they spent so much money and tried to rebuild the brand around. I can see two probable outcomes from Disney LucasFilm in the event that the New Jedi Order movie underperforms, depending on how badly it underperforms. If it does so-so but not great, LucasFilm will probably have Rey succumb to the usual Jedi mentor occupational hazard and whoever's the most popular secondary character with fans replaces her as the protagonist for the rest of the New Jedi Order storyline. If the film is a bomb, LucasFilm will can the rest of their plans for New Jedi Order, retire the rest of Rey's storyline to the EU, and try to move on from the sequel trilogy era. We'll see... they've got some far-past sequel in development called Dawn of the Jedi, which is allegedly set 25,000 years in the past.- 344 replies
-
- star wars
- episode vi
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
- Today
-
All Things Videogame Related: EXTREME VS!!
sh9000 replied to Keith's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
- 6922 replies
-
- Video games
- PS3
-
(and 12 more)
Tagged with:
-
Macross Plus Ultimate Edition Blu-ray Release Thread
sh9000 replied to sh9000's topic in Movies and TV Series
https://store.crunchyroll.com/products/macross-plus-movie-ova-blu-ray-ultimate-edition-crunchyroll-exclusive-5037899090312.html- 225 replies
-
- macross plus
- ultimate edition
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Which is a similar problem with the sequel trilogy. Such great actors reduced to wooden performances and simplistic dialogue. "I hate sand." "Somehow Palpatine returned." I'd say though, that the 'simplicity' of the fairy tale could do well with a bit of Andor'esq spice, especially considering the general love Andor is receiving. Considering ANH as a beginning, then showing such an emotional growth and complexity in later movies/shows would be a good thing. TFA didn't do that. It rebooted the story from the 'beginning' rather than really continuing anything. If the next two had grown from it with a concise and planned storyline rather than the willy-nilly-sillyness that JJ/Kennedy went for, the discussions would be entirely different. Such as now, we're expecting them to to just reboot Luke's story post RoTJ, only with Rey now. That's why I'm a proponent of just refilming 7 thru 9 entirely, even knowing that is an impossibility. If I had my druthers, they'd recast Luke, Leia and Han and start filming the EU, even though that mess also has its faults. With neither of that happening, the next trilogy centering on Rey needs to shift entirely from what came before, and following the more dramatic and well-paced vein of Andor is by far the better option. As to newer stories, I really hope the series focusing on the High Republic era, something far too early to be connected, does really well. And that they finally learn from last few shows, the good and the bad.
- 344 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- star wars
- episode vi
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
-
Is the Gamecube already considered retro gaming? Probably the last Gamecube game I am going to buy for the collection.
- 2025 replies
-
- video games
- old school
-
(and 11 more)
Tagged with:
-
Thanks, it sounds like I may have over-reacted a tad but didn't want anyone caught unawares if possible.
-
- 494 replies
-
- toys
- just purchased
- (and 14 more)
-
Well, they came back and said I had to pay shipping because of tariffs. $14 for shipping from China isn’t so bad. So hopefully I’ll have my not “jetfire” soon.
-
All Things Videogame Related: EXTREME VS!!
TangledThorns replied to Keith's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
Hopefully its good as THE EXPANSE was one of my favorite sci-fi series in the past ten years.- 6922 replies
-
- Video games
- PS3
-
(and 12 more)
Tagged with:
-
True! And Hobby JAPAN just released a photo shoot of Bandai's HG Turbo Custom, with some nice weathering.
- 2483 replies
-
- Armored Trooper VOTOMS
- Votoms
-
(and 6 more)
Tagged with:
-
Predator: Killer of Killers - June 6
Duke Togo replied to sh9000's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
He had a stroke several years ago.- 26 replies
-
- predator
- 20th century studios
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Super Macross Mecha Fun Time Discussion Thread!
SebastianP replied to Valkyrie Driver's topic in Movies and TV Series
And what I'm saying is that *Studio Nue* did not care about making anything in true scale. The whole issue goes back to the Stargazer, which *should never have been a Northampton*, because there already were two carriers that were very under-utilized in the show. The precedent of the Stargazer I think why anyone even looked at the Northampton as a basis for the Gefion in the first place. I can buy most of the rest of your arguments, except that "the larger carriers would have been too dominant" - a Guantanamo, especially the true size version that they used for the cool launch shots in the Frontier opening battle, would have been smaller by some significant margin than they ended up making the Gefion, and been visually less threatening because of the lack of big guns, and would have had room for Aisha's VF collection and any other cast members, *and* been justified in that a VF development project obviously needs a carrier of some sort if it's not going to be land-based. -
If it helps, I just measured it and it’s 8cm height till the tip of head lasers.
- 494 replies
-
- toys
- just purchased
- (and 14 more)
-
It may be totally unrelated, but I've been seeing a lot more Metal Structure Nu's on Mandarake lately.
- 8464 replies
-
The Unlicensed Third Party Transformers Thread
shazam replied to slaginpit's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
- 9309 replies
-
- fans toys
- mastermind creations
- (and 19 more)
-
Technical Stuff that i'm very interested in: Positive improvements for some games
-
Super Macross Mecha Fun Time Discussion Thread!
Seto Kaiba replied to Valkyrie Driver's topic in Movies and TV Series
It's a video game, bro... I guarantee you the dev team literally did not care about making anything in true scale. 🤣 What Artdink's dev team did care about was picking a design for the Gefion that plausibly fit with the premise of the game's story. The SMS branch on Uroboros is not there to provide PMC services to Uroboros's government. They're not even really meant to be a combat unit at all. They're a well-funded, but minimally staffed, R&D unit led by an eccentric senior researcher. Their mission is to study the intense and widespread fold fault activity around the planet and work on ways for fold faults to be traversed safely. The minimal staffing and remote location make secrecy easier to maintain. In practical terms, that meant the Gefion needed to be: An escort warship large enough to plausibly hold 3-4 Variable Fighters for the main cast. Small enough to not dominate the area map in any of the game's zones and plausibly be operated by a handful of people. Lacking in offensive power to the point that SMS cannot plausibly overpower the other factions in the game using it. Visually communicate that SMS Uroboros is a small operation lacking the resources of a dedicated combat unit. The Northampton-class was a pretty ideal choice there, since it was a design used in Macross Frontier and its movies, it's a very small and lightly armed stealth warship, and it has been shown to carry ~3 Variable Fighters in normal operating conditions (in Macross 7). They just slapped some catapult decks on the side because that linear catapult launch in the Macross Frontier series is so dang satisfying. The scale's off a bit, sure, and once you've got a dozen or so support characters you start to wonder where they're putting everyone... but that was a lower priority than finding something that fit the bill, looked nice doing it, and worked naturally with the game. The only other pre-existing design that would have fit the bill would be the Valhalla III-type from Macross Digital Mission VF-X... which would've been kind of badass in its own right but the catapult launch on that one would've been much more complex and possibly induce motion sickness. Using one of the larger carrier classes was right out. They're too big, they imply too much power at SMS's disposal, and the player is naturally going to wonder why a ship that was designed to hold multiple squadrons of Variable Fighters only has one other pilot - who is also the ship's captain - aboard at the start of the game. -
Predator: Killer of Killers - June 6
TangledThorns replied to sh9000's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
I thought it was well made. There is only so much you can do with the PREDATOR and it seems they are pushing it more than ever before. Also, Michael Biehn's age seems to be taking a toll on him as he sounded much older than he really is.- 26 replies
-
- predator
- 20th century studios
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Post Skywalker Saga Star Wars Movies
Seto Kaiba replied to jvmacross's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
Naturally. Even the very finest actors cannot save a production with a garbage script and lackluster direction. Ms. Ridley herself is not the problem. She can only do her best with what she's given. The problem facing New Jedi Order is that they're trying to sell another movie based on a character whose audience reception hovers somewhere between total ambivalence and general antipathy. The writers of the sequel trilogy did a very poor job with Rey as a character and it's going to be very difficult, potentially impossible, for her to win over the crowd now. The kind of writing that works for stories like Andor doesn't really work for something like a Jedi-centric story. The Jedi and the Sith exist in a simpler, more child-friendly context where morality is reduced to a simple matter of Good vs. Evil, where the villains are melodramatic evil sorcerers and blood knights, and where the Chosen Hero of Destiny saves the day every time. You can't have that AND do grounded, morally complex, realistic writing like Andor's... they're antithecal premises. A lot of classic fantasy stories started out as folk tales... little bits of oral mytho-history, fairy tales, and folkloric explanations for the weirdness of the natural world. They're short and to the point because they exist to teach a simple moral lesson, to teach children what not to do, or just explain weird sh*t that happens naturally. Sequels, prequels, all that hot nonsense has existed for a long time too. One could argue that Homer's Odyssey was a sequel to his Iliad. Those existed more in the realms of complex, bawdy, and bloody mytho-history meant for the theatergoing adult. Commercial sequels... it's hard to say how old those truly are. Shakespeare did at least one, that being Henry IV Part II, but even that wasn't really making stuff up off the cuff to keep a story going past its end. They do imply that the war we see in the OT is only one that's happened, so it's justified even without showing another. I think moving far enough down the timeline that everyone from the originals is long dead would be a good move. They don't want to because they want to lean on all that residual goodwill audiences have for the existing cast. Developing new factions, a new main cast, and new designs all from scratch is a hard and a big investment... something they were burned by in the sequel trilogy. They can try to maintain stasis, much like how The Acolyte looks essentially no different to the "modern day" despite being 100+ years apart, but that's unsatifying in its own way. Kind of a damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don't situation IMO... but at this point they have little to lose now that Andor's over and the best they have in the pipe is more unintentionally sexist displays of girl power putting the entire galaxy in danger in Ahsoka season two.- 344 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- star wars
- episode vi
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
- Yesterday
-
That’s interesting, I’d love to hear that they included a Kakizaki figure as well, now I’ll have to check. Although that’s definitely some wishful thinking on my part
-
Fantasies rarely had a sequel because they were usually short stories up til maybe dime novels started and eventually Tolkien wrote a story with sequels and prequels and all kinds of things. The idea of milking a franchise is probably older than what I mentioned. Star Wars implies that there’s more than one just from the title. But in my personal opinion any sequel war would have been more interesting if it was much further in the future and just had side stories or smaller stories between that time. To upset the balance of the force kinda thing shouldn’t have been so immediate after the og trilogy ended.
- 344 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- star wars
- episode vi
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with: