Yeah.. they are both so similar with their respective plus & minuses, is that to me the only way to personally decide which one’s better is to ironically have both in hand.
One feature I love about Arcadia’s over Bandai’s, is the way the cockpit opens. Whether canon or not, or by toy design legacy stretching all the way back to the Yammie is that for the front canopy to open properly, the anti-glare bit ahead of it need to be recessed.
It’s an additional step, but the canopy looks much smarter in this open position compared to Bandai’s.
It’s a brilliant design touch and I display my Arcadia this way.