Andor (Star Wars: Andor) - Disney+

[jvmacross]

11 hours ago, Big s said:

Senator Binx was too loyal to the empire to be imprisoned by them.

That's Sentor Binx in a New Republic cell.....lol

[Big s]

1 hour ago, jvmacross said:

That's Sentor Binx in a New Republic cell.....lol

I don’t think the new republic really had prison cells, just transport ships where prisoners escape easily and become pirates or First Order members. 
I think Binx and Deedra met in transition and that’s where Phasma was conceived. that’s how Phasma gained her luck abilities, unfortunately Dedra’s bad luck powers counteracted Binx’s doof luck powers.

[Seto Kaiba]

12 hours ago, Big s said:

Senator Binx was too loyal to the empire to be imprisoned by them.

Supervisor Meero almost certainly believed the same was true of herself.

That she was surely too loyal to the Empire to ever be arrested and sent to a space gulag.

Spoiler

Then she FAFO'd by actively interfering in another Supervisor's investigation and arrest and accessing documents she had no clearance for, and discovered that the Empire really doesn't give a sh*t about her loyalty.

I can only imagine the vast numbers of people who might begin dreaming up false charges in order to free themselves from Senator Binks's company.🤣

 

 

1 hour ago, jvmacross said:

That's Sentor Binx in a New Republic cell.....lol

1 minute ago, Big s said:

I don’t think the new republic really had prison cells, just transport ships where prisoners escape easily and become pirates or First Order members. 
I think Binx and Deedra met in transition and that’s where Phasma was conceived. that’s how Phasma gained her luck abilities, unfortunately Dedra’s bad luck powers counteracted Binx’s doof luck powers.

Most of the Empire's prisons were Republic and/or Separatist prisons first... and probably went right back to being Republic prisons after the war.

The only thing more horrible than that hypothesis is the cursed knowledge imparted to me by The Clone Wars... the terrible, forbidden knowledge that...

Spoiler

Abandon hope, ye who enter here...

Spoiler

Seriously, some things you're better off not knowing.

Spoiler

... Jar-Jar Binks canonically f*cks.

We meet his lover, who is a Queen on another planet, in The Clone Wars's sixth season.

 

[sh9000]

She did a great job.

[TangledThorns]

Finished the second season. Just as f'ing good as the first. I'm hoping we get to see more of this. A series about the second Death Star would be very interesting. But who knows with Disney...

[Roy Focker]

1 hour ago, TangledThorns said:

Finished the second season. Just as f'ing good as the first. I'm hoping we get to see more of this. A series about the second Death Star would be very interesting. But who knows with Disney...

Unless the timeline has been changed there are 3 years between Episodes IV & V. Then a 1/2 year between V & VI. You could cover the 2nd Death Star, show how they captured the Imperial Shuttle, killed those Bothans, the move from Yavin to Hoth. They covered the years leading up to Yavin and a few years after Endor. The movies only covered the big battles. You still tell stories about smaller skirmishes in the war. I'm 100% sure all of it has been covered in some novel or comic book, but live action Star Wars is the most interesting when the good guys are the underdogs. 

[Seto Kaiba]

51 minutes ago, Roy Focker said:

I'm 100% sure all of it has been covered in some novel or comic book, but live action Star Wars is the most interesting when the good guys are the underdogs. 

Some parts of that story are likely too unremarkable/mundane/boring to bother putting into a series too.

For instance, the theft of the shuttle is probably a nonevent.  Rebels steal Imperial shuttles so often in Star Wars shows that how easily and how often they're stolen has become a bit of an in-story running joke across multiple series.  

"How is it the Empire lets us keep stealing these things?" - Kanan Jarrus

[TangledThorns]

Also want to note how the soundtrack was perfect for the tone of the series too. 

 

 

[sh9000]

Very cool.

[Big s]

On 5/24/2025 at 7:54 AM, TangledThorns said:

Also want to note how the soundtrack was perfect for the tone of the series too. 

 

 

I wouldn’t say perfect, that dance music just didn’t fit

[TangledThorns]

Wait for it... 😂🤣

 

 

[renegadeleader1]

On 5/23/2025 at 9:40 PM, Roy Focker said:

Unless the timeline has been changed there are 3 years between Episodes IV & V. Then a 1/2 year between V & VI. You could cover the 2nd Death Star, show how they captured the Imperial Shuttle, killed those Bothans, the move from Yavin to Hoth. They covered the years leading up to Yavin and a few years after Endor. The movies only covered the big battles. You still tell stories about smaller skirmishes in the war. I'm 100% sure all of it has been covered in some novel or comic book, but live action Star Wars is the most interesting when the good guys are the underdogs. 

Dedra redemption arc. Her getting inadvertently getting busted out of prison during a rebel prison break and joining the rebellion where her knowledge of imperial security procedures would be invaluable. Her losing everything as she has would give her a new understanding and value of Luthen's talk of freedom to her. It would also be fitting if her actions again have unforseen consequences with her being the one that sets the Emperor's trap into motion. Doubly so if she senses it's a trap, but gets shouted down because she's not trusted by someone like Klaya who would see the battle of endor as a final confrontation to end it all and fulfill her and Luthen's dream of a galaxy without the Empire.

[Big s]

6 hours ago, renegadeleader1 said:

Dedra redemption arc. Her getting inadvertently getting busted out of prison during a rebel prison break and joining the rebellion where her knowledge of imperial security procedures would be invaluable. Her losing everything as she has would give her a new understanding and value of Luthen's talk of freedom to her. It would also be fitting if her actions again have unforseen consequences with her being the one that sets the Emperor's trap into motion. Doubly so if she senses it's a trap, but gets shouted down because she's not trusted by someone like Klaya who would see the battle of endor as a final confrontation to end it all and fulfill her and Luthen's dream of a galaxy without the Empire.

It is very possible she’d be broken out with the rest of the rebels. As I said a few posts back, she was listed as a rebel spy and there’s not many left alive if anyone that could even dispute that 

[Seto Kaiba]

5 hours ago, renegadeleader1 said:

Dedra redemption arc. Her getting inadvertently getting busted out of prison during a rebel prison break and joining the rebellion where her knowledge of imperial security procedures would be invaluable. Her losing everything as she has would give her a new understanding and value of Luthen's talk of freedom to her.

Oh please no.  That's so dumb and it would ruin her entire character arc.

Meero's role in the story, like Karn's, is to show that the Empire emphatically does not care about anyone.  The Empire's authoritarian desire for total control means that deviation from its edicts is seen as a challenge to its authority and punished without mercy, no matter how loyal or well-intentioned that person is.  It's only ever a matter of time before the regime turns on and destroys even its most mindlessly loyal lackeys for some perceived or actual failure, mistake, or misstep. 

Dedra Meero was a true believer in the Empire and the ISB's particularly draconian idea of "justice".  She all but unflinchingly ordered a genocide for the Empire's benefit.  Neither her lifelong loyalty nor her professional achievements in the Empire's service mattered a damn once she finally made a mistake that affected the Empire's objectives.  She wound up sent to be worked to death in the very same prison labor camps she spent her days shipping people to.  That irony is the perfect end to her story.

A redemption arc would be absolutely ridiculous... not only is Meero someone who absolutely loathes the Rebellion, there's no way the Rebels are going to overlook what she's done.  Not only did she likely send many thousands of people to prison labor camps like Narkina to be worked to death, she literally orchestrated a genocide.  The very genocide that directly led to the formation of the Rebel Alliance. 

Spoiler

Considering the rather blatant reference to the Wannsee Conference in the season's first episode, Dedra Meero's basically Star Wars's version of real world war criminal Adolf Eichmann.  Like Eichmann, once justice catches up to her she's headed for trial and the gallows... not a pardon and future employment.

 

There's already a better character for that role from the same period too... ISB Agent Kallus.

[Big s]

2 hours ago, Seto Kaiba said:

.  Like Eichmann, once justice catches up to her she's headed for trial and the gallows... not a pardon and future employment.

Unfortunately, everyone that knew of her crimes is pretty much dead. All they have on record is that she was a rebel spy that leaked information about the Deathstar, making her a rebel hero by mistake.

[renegadeleader1]

1 hour ago, Seto Kaiba said:

Oh please no.  That's so dumb and it would ruin her entire character arc.

Meero's role in the story, like Karn's, is to show that the Empire emphatically does not care about anyone.  The Empire's authoritarian desire for total control means that deviation from its edicts is seen as a challenge to its authority and punished without mercy, no matter how loyal or well-intentioned that person is.  It's only ever a matter of time before the regime turns on and destroys even its most mindlessly loyal lackeys for some perceived or actual failure, mistake, or misstep. 

Dedra Meero was a true believer in the Empire and the ISB's particularly draconian idea of "justice".  She all but unflinchingly ordered a genocide for the Empire's benefit.  Neither her lifelong loyalty nor her professional achievements in the Empire's service mattered a damn once she finally made a mistake that affected the Empire's objectives.  She wound up sent to be worked to death in the very same prison labor camps she spent her days shipping people to.  That irony is the perfect end to her story.

A redemption arc would be absolutely ridiculous... not only is Meero someone who absolutely loathes the Rebellion, there's no way the Rebels are going to overlook what she's done.  Not only did she likely send many thousands of people to prison labor camps like Narkina to be worked to death, she literally orchestrated a genocide.  The very genocide that directly led to the formation of the Rebel Alliance. 

  Reveal hidden contents

Considering the rather blatant reference to the Wannsee Conference in the season's first episode, Dedra Meero's basically Star Wars's version of real world war criminal Adolf Eichmann.  Like Eichmann, once justice catches up to her she's headed for trial and the gallows... not a pardon and future employment.

 

There's already a better character for that role from the same period too... ISB Agent Kallus.

You're not really making a solid argument why it isn't a good idea. As you stated Dedra is a morally ambiguous character with a massive taint from her past actions who has had her entire world view shattered, lost her love, lost her freedom, and has been literally tossed aside like garbage by the entire thing she dedicated her life to. An unhinged thirst for revenge is a hell of a motivation, and lets face it Dedra is the type that would sacrifice a whole planet worth of Bothans to accomplish a mission especially if it means getting retribution against the establishment that she feels discarded her.

[renegadeleader1]

4 minutes ago, Big s said:

Unfortunately, everyone that knew of her crimes is pretty much dead. All they have on record is that she was a rebel spy that leaked information about the Deathstar, making her a rebel hero by mistake.

Like Krennic said, "You missed your calling as a rebel spy."

 

I like to think that's forshadowing.

[Seto Kaiba]

55 minutes ago, Big s said:

Unfortunately, everyone that knew of her crimes is pretty much dead. All they have on record is that she was a rebel spy that leaked information about the Deathstar, making her a rebel hero by mistake.

That's demonstrably untrue... even just within the context of Andor itself.

Dedra Meero was an ISB supervisor who was in charge of multiple sectors and a major conflict zone (Ghorman).  She wasn't quite a public figure, but she was someone that was under scrutiny by the Ghorman Front, by Luthen's agents, and by other rebel groups.  As we know from multiple stories, most of those groups shared intelligence.

There's also two years between the Ghorman Massacre and the events of Rogue One in which survivors of the Ghorman Front, Cassian Andor, and possibly K-2SO could share all their intelligence with the newly formed Rebel Alliance.  Plus the Alliance also has Kleya, who knows all about Dedra Meero and many other top-ranking ISB operatives.  Not only that, but the Ghorman Massacre was one of the Empire's worst public atrocities and individuals involved in it would naturally have been marked as war criminals that the Rebel Alliance (and New Republic) would wantt o bring to trial.  (The briefing room scene where Cassian relays Kleya's message suggests the Alliance is well aware of who the ISB's supervisors are and what they've done.)

So no... it's not like all information on Dedra Meero and her war crimes magically disappeared and she can be mistaken for a rebel spy.  The very idea is ridiculous.

 

51 minutes ago, renegadeleader1 said:

You're not really making a solid argument why it isn't a good idea. As you stated Dedra is a morally ambiguous character [...]

Uh, no... no I did not.

In fact, what I stated was the opposite.  That Dedra Meero is a True Believer in the Empire and the ISB's vision of Imperial Justice.  There is nothing morally ambiguous about her.  She is full-on Lawful Evil.  Two entire seasons of the series clearly show that she is not in any way conflicted about her role in the ISB.  She's blase about mass arrest quotas and the detainees being worked to death in prison labor camps.  She quite calmly advocates that a captured rebel pilot be murdered to avoid tipping off his compatriots that he had been captured.  On Ferrix, she's shown to be enjoying herself watching Dr. Gorse torture suspected Rebel agents like Bix and Salman Paak to the brink of insanity with audio recordings of a genocide as a way of collecting intelligence and has no problem with the local prefect executing Salman by hanging afterward.  She not only proposes a Final Solution to the "Ghorman problem" at Krennic's conference, she personally creates the conditions for the Ghorman Massacre to occur and then gives the order to start the massacre herself.  She justifies the massacre to her boyfriend as necessary to advance their careers.

The only time she's ever shown to be in any way bothered by what she does is when her boyfriend attempts to wring her neck after learning that she's actively trying to make the situation on Ghorman worse, and he ends up dead as a result.

Her role in season two is a very overt echo of a real world war criminal responsible for a genocide.  That's not moral ambiguity, that's genuine evil.  Not the cackling melodramatic kind embodied by Emperor Palpatine, but unambiguous evil nonetheless.

 

51 minutes ago, renegadeleader1 said:

[...] with a massive taint from her past actions who has had her entire world view shattered, lost her love, lost her freedom, and has been literally tossed aside like garbage by the entire thing she dedicated her life to. An unhinged thirst for revenge is a hell of a motivation, and lets face it Dedra is the type that would sacrifice a whole planet worth of Bothans to accomplish a mission especially if it means getting retribution against the establishment that she feels discarded her.

What makes you assume her thirst for revenge would be focused on the Empire?

Remember, the Empire is what she believes in.  What she has devoted her entire life to.  What literally raised her, according to her own account of her past to Eedy.  Her service to the ISB and the Empire is practically her entire identity and her faith in the Empire is practically absolute.  The Rebels utterly disgust her, as we see on many occasions in the series.

And remember, when Director Krennic confronts her in the ISB interrogation room on Coruscant, we see her put two and two together VERY quickly and realize that the person who stole her credentials and accessed the files about the Death Star that had been mistakenly sent to her was a Rebel agent and the person responsible for the leak.  As far as Dedra's concerned, she's in that prison because a rebel spy broke into her files and destroyed her career.  That's not likely to endear the Rebellion to her.

Not to mention, of course, that a "redemption" arc would be a boneheaded reversal of her entire character arc across both seasons of the show.  It's like proposing a redemption arc for Tarkin... he's a Complete Monster, those don't get redeemed they get destroyed.

Edited 1 hour ago by Seto Kaiba

[renegadeleader1]

18 minutes ago, Seto Kaiba said:

he's a Complete Monster, those don't get redeemed they get destroyed.

I can recall a certain character that that was a complete monster that killed children, carried out multiple genocides, executed, and tortured prisoners that somehow got a redemption arc. 😆

[Big s]

47 minutes ago, Seto Kaiba said:

That's demonstrably untrue... even just within the context of Andor itself.

Dedra Meero was an ISB supervisor who was in charge of multiple sectors and a major conflict zone (Ghorman).  She wasn't quite a public figure, but she was someone that was under scrutiny by the Ghorman Front, by Luthen's agents, and by other rebel groups.  As we know from multiple stories, most of those groups shared intelligence.

There's also two years between the Ghorman Massacre and the events of Rogue One in which survivors of the Ghorman Front, Cassian Andor, and possibly K-2SO could share all their intelligence with the newly formed Rebel Alliance.  Plus the Alliance also has Kleya, who knows all about Dedra Meero and many other top-ranking ISB operatives.  Not only that, but the Ghorman Massacre was one of the Empire's worst public atrocities and individuals involved in it would naturally have been marked as war criminals that the Rebel Alliance (and New Republic) would wantt o bring to trial.  (The briefing room scene where Cassian relays Kleya's message suggests the Alliance is well aware of who the ISB's supervisors are and what they've done.)

So no... it's not like all information on Dedra Meero and her war crimes magically disappeared and she can be mistaken for a rebel spy.  The very idea is ridiculous.

Basically everyone you listed died and the rebels don’t seem to trust information from other factions easily. Kleya might end up the only one and she probably wouldn’t have been the one to break her or other prisoners out. Not only that, but who knows if Kleya survived much past this point. They could just as easily write her as KIA or just quit and ended up a death stick addict.

 

30 minutes ago, renegadeleader1 said:

I can recall a certain character that that was a complete monster that killed children, carried out multiple genocides, executed, and tortured prisoners that somehow got a redemption arc. 😆

and now he’s an undead force ghost with a cool, very much younger and fully intact body.