im for it if ONLY nothing is changed. i mean NOTHING. just improve the animation, make the characters look like DYRL and since ur already planning it, CG the valks. besides that... imo, NO adding scenes, NO changing camera angles, etc, none of that. if thats what you had in mind... i say, im all for it.
if that was ur plan, i dont see why people would be against it. its a fan thing. it'll just be for us fans that wants it to enjoy. it isnt like we're going to market it and have it hit american tv and so on and so forth. riiiiight?
im pretty sure i can show it to a friend or two that might be able to draw them into macross. hehehe...