Duke Togo

I'm pretty sure in one of the novels Wedge flat out states that he's not related to the good Captain. the novels are EU, they aren't canon.

Antillies is *supposed* to be a fairly common Corellian name, kinda like Smith or Jones. But, its widely reported that Denis Lawson was offered the role of Captain Antilles in Episode III, which would lead you to believe...

From what I understand, the original novel states that the Tantive IV is of Corellian origin. Take that with a grain of salt, the novels are practically EU.

Isn't Captain Antilles the dude who gets his neck snapped by Vader in the first few minutes of ANH. Yeah, that's him. He seems to be another one of these characters that the Prequels have messed with age wise. He doesn't seem to age much between III and IV, while Obi Wan aged what, 30 years? And there are only 20 years between the two episodes?

That's not what I've heard. First off, we don't know where Captain Antilles is from. Secondly, why would he ask DENIS Lawson to play the character if there was not to be some relation? Third, its not a re-used name, Captain Antilles was mentioned in the Original Trilogy. Now Bail Antilles, he is from Alderaan.

They are related, they are not the same person. Lucas had asked Denis Lawson (Wedge) to play the role of the older Antilles, but he turned it down.

I am all over this toy! That's a must have.

That's what Lucas himself has said, which is one of the reasons why I am so wary of the EU.

How about this... You're an asspipe, pardon my french.

LOL, hardly. And I am SO glad to see the federal government spending so much time fighting this copyright infringers, instead of focusing on less important matters, such as securing our borders and terrorism.

Ok, this is sad. Now they are ranking top 5 day openings, top 6 day... what the hell? Are we just going to keep rankings on every day its top? Jesus Christ, do these people not have something better to do with their time (like posting about cartoons on a message board or something...)?

My only problem here is that after actually taking the time to look into other discussions and debates on this topic elsewhere, its quite clear that neither the movies nor Lucas have been quite clear (no matter what Hurin thinks).

Are we talking outside of his voice here? I don't recall actually seeing him in the movie.

Having read all of that (for what reason I don't know), outside of maybe one or two instances where I could have worded things better, I have no clue where you are getting all of that from. That said, there isn't a chance in hell I am going to respond to all of that, point by point. I'm not that farting dumb.

I found a thread just for you, Hurin: http://boards.theforce.net/The_Star_Wars_S...6/12176359/?154 Go have fun.

While we are on the subject, I just upgraded my CPU, mobo, and VPU on Monday. I'm now running a Powercolor Radeon X800 XL 256Bit/256MB VIVO PCI-E card. Love it.

I'd recommend the Radeon 9600 XT 128Bit/256MB.

I missed it, what exactly blew up in my face? And just because you state something doesn't mean anything I've said is instantly wrong. I said it before and I'll say it again, if the answer was that clear, this wouldn't be an ongoing discussion in the Star Wars fan community. I stand by my argument.

Yes, now you understand it. Anakin wipes out the Jedi, then the Sith. Balance is achieved. Luke is literally the heir to this.

And you completely miss the fact that nowhere in the Saga is the truth behind this clear. Lucas himself has changed his story several times on the subject. The only answers generally come from the EU (which generally support my argument, which is amusing, because I don't really like the EU).

Yes, that's me, and nowhere in that post did I state that Luke is the one who brings balance to the Force.

Roll your eyes all you want, but its true. Should we start involving the so called "Dark Jedi" in this discussion? You can sit and read through not just what little we have said here, but the pages upon pages of discussions and articles elsewhere, and come to the conclusion that there is no conclusion. Otherwise, this wouldn't be an ongoing debate.

Um, no its not. Where the hell did you get that from?

I've spent some time now poking around other message boards, reading discussions on this topic, and I have come to the conclusion that Lucas farted all of this up. There is no one answer here, no right or wrong answer. The truth is, its unknown. The only answers you will really get are from the EU, which isn't canon. Too many contridictions.