hmm after compilation by an extremly advanced computer (my own brain) here my list(V.F. pilots, no other mecha) :
1. Maximillian Jenius
2. Milla Fallyna Jenius (no question here)
3. Isamu Dyson (based on his pure piloting skill, since he is the most likely to be hit by "friendly" fire)
4. Hikaru Ichijo (you got to give him some credit somehow)
5. Roy Focker
6. D.D. Ivanov
7. Aegis Focker(why that guy is here? Isamu was crazy enough to assault the Macross, but Aegis was more crazy than him since he attacked Battle 13)
8. Guld Bowman
9. Ozma Lee
10. Alto Saotome(lower than ozma, he has amazing piloting skills but they are often displayed when he is damn angry or desperate enough, in short : he lack consistence)
11. Shin Kudo
12. Michael Blanc
13. Nora Polyanski
13. Brera Sterne
14. Ray Lovelock
15. Gamlin Kizaki
16. Henry Gilliam
17. Luca Angeloni
18. Canaria Berstein
guess who last : Kakizaki Hayao