I'm going to have to say Roy. Not only was he able to pull the team together (watch your Wingman!) and focus on the Mission at hand, he was able to do so while drunk! Let's not forget, that Mylia flew in with an entire squadron of Q'Rau (forgive my spelling!) and while Max was off giving an overconfident Mylia the business, her squadron is not around to retreat with her. What happened to them? Roy happened!!! While Max proves to be the Supernatural Prodigy in Macross, Roy's kill record remains unbroken. How do you beat a 101 kill (Breaking even the RED BARON's kill record) head start? Yes, Max is the most agile pilot and even the most legendary, but flying loop di loops is for the air circuses (note the irony here). I say, let the numbers speak for themselves. Roy all the way!!!