-
Posts
3831 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Posts posted by davidwhangchoi
-
-
18 hours ago, Chronocidal said:
Up on AE, go one no fuss.
https://anime-export.com/index.php?product=97550
HLJ seems to be having web issues though, it's listed on the main page, but the link is dead. Seems that they added all of the Bandai products to the front page, but none of the individual item pages are ready.
Edit: Working now:
https://www.hlj.com/dx-chogokin-vf-17s-nightmare-stealth-valkyrie-gamlin-kizaki-s-banc692672
lol hlj limit is 1 per customer... i'm not sure who wants 2.
BBTS is $299... i won't criticize BBTS for this, perhaps that is the msrp price for the US that is set by Bandai,
someone must be smoking rocks or out of touch setting that MSRP
-
-
18 hours ago, Graham said:
For further comparison of the VF-17S vs the VF-171, here's the 'detall-up' VF-17 lineart showing full panel lines and other details.
IIRC, these pics were first seen in the "Macross 7 Animation Materials" book, published in 1995.
Credit to macross2.net for the pic, saves me having to scan the page from my book. 😅
Interestingly, despite their simplified transformation and limited articulation, the old Bandai 1/65 scale VF-17D/S toys from the 90s actually feature most of the panel lines from the detail-up lineart.
There is so much detail difference and proportional difference between the VF-17 and the VF-171. You just cannot use VF-171 legs and most other parts of a VF-171 and call it a VF-17......sigh.
Being a huge VF-17 fan, the more I look at the Bandai DX photos, the more depressed I get.
Thanks @Graham
this is illustration is the cleanest image of the VF-17. esp. the underside of fighter, seeing how wide legs could be stored underneath...
-
@PointBlankSniper @Chronocidal
Images of the VF-17 and VF-171 from the same video that claims the legs are the same. I can't understand Japanese so you'll have to re-confirm if you can understand native Japanese or if it's possible it was misunderstood (as i can't confirm it one way or the other with the link you provided).
Anyhow, the scale comparison in the video displays the 17 and 171 vall side by side and i found a video just for the 17 and screen grabbed further images.
-
5 hours ago, PointBlankSniper said:
Think it was this one. He credited master file and some other publication.
Thanks @PointBlankSniper, really appreciate the link. i remember watching this youtube channel and may have posted another one of the channels video on here in the past.
-
3 hours ago, PointBlankSniper said:
What's at hand here is not a matter of how it's depicted in animation. It's that Kawamori or some supplementary magazine or some other product blurb invented some lore and set the stage for Bandai to be lazy here.
we're digressing, the whole point is what it looks like in the anime.
I was responding just to one point of your comment to Chronocidal.
I agree with some of your points but I wanted to debunk just one specific point.
You brought up a point of the 171 and 17 have the same leg sizes and it's the CG vs. M7 art style the reason the proportions look different. I was responding that it isn't the reason the 171 looks thinner than the vf-17 by comparison of a CG VF-1 compared with M7 and SDF-1 TV/DYRL Macross depicts the VF-1 consistently, CG or not. Kawamori at the helm of all these shows he's going to make sure the VF-1 are proportionately the same CG or not. So the 171 being done in CG is not a great reason for the difference in leg size between the 171 and 17.
if you can link me to the source of the material that says the 171 and 17 legs are identical in size, I'd appreciate it. (i'd like to read up and crappy General Galaxy designs)
but yes, I agree with you, Bandai sucks with this one.
-
On 9/25/2025 at 9:55 PM, PointBlankSniper said:
To put it differently, if 171 was drawn in M7 style, it would be just as chonky as 17.
I haven't looked up the 171 lore so i don't have a dispute with you there,
but comparing the CG valks found in Frontier/Delta vs. M7, I'm going to call B.S. on this specific point.
the VF-1 in Frontier and Delta that is done in CG looks exactly the same vs. M7, specially, the legs of the valk between Frontier, Delta and M7 are drawn identically.
If that's the case in point I would think the vf-1 would be more chonky or see a difference between M7 and the later CG models.
for reference:
- M7 Ep. 14
- MacF Ep.1
- Delta Ep.3
-
-
What's with these collabs?
Mattel isn't even Hasbro. How bout JEM Arcee?
-
-
5 hours ago, Mog said:
Don’t put that evil on us!
Especially when there’s a perfectly promising TV style prototype just collecting dust somewhere.
2 hours ago, Chronocidal said:I think the topic here is much more about the proportions of the jet itself than the individual parts. For all of the changes between them, the YF-19 and VF-19 are still fundamentally the same aircraft design, with the same layout and overall proportions of components relative to each other.
That really can't be said about the 17 and 171, because their proportions are really nothing alike in battroid mode. Obviously moving to CG animation changed the magical proportion shifts present in Macross 7, but that didn't stop Yamato from making a massively chonky brute of a VF-17, and getting it to transform into a solid fighter mode.
Bandai made an accurate VF-171, sure. But it looks nothing like what the VF-17 ever has, in any medium.
They may as well be trying to upsell an F-18C as a Super Hornet. The designs are at least that different.
100%
2 hours ago, nightmareB4macross said:ahahaha, that drawing...
This site is the best
-
9 hours ago, Chronocidal said:
Which, funny enough, I think I would have been more on-board with?
They could have marketed it under the Macross 30 game license, since it included a bunch of alternate color 171s I would have loved.
On that note though, this might give us the red Millia 17S I always wanted, but Yamato never did. I'll definitely bite on that one, if it happens.
All things considered though, I might still grab one or two of these down the road. They won't replace the Yammies, but I'll be very curious to see how it sells, and whether it winds up in the Amazon bargain bin (where it really belongs). They'll stay in fighter forever, but I can't say the design is terrible in that mode anyhow.
At the very least it'll be a nice source of spare parts to repair more of my 171 junk pile.
yes, i will wait for Amazon clearance for this one...
Bandai with Frontier and Delta series had good original toys designs that were created together alongside the new show from ground up to market. Good or bad, those designs were original as they were created with the anime.
-designing toys retroactively for past anime, Bandai steals the majority of the designs improvements of the VF-19 and VF-1 off Arcadia's engineering revisions.
-(19's sweep wings, everything off the VF-1 ver. 2 ) VF-0D's hi-metals. Bandai seems decent at copying and making it a bit better.
-the Dx YF-21 didn't really have a revision to steal from and came out a mixed bag. I guarantee Arcadia, if they are still alive and had a budget, would do a much better revision of the YF-21.
M7 is pretty much looks like a Redeco line up. TF generation 2 toys.
Minor alterations to the 19 to make a fire valk.
and the laziest Redeco, slap on a new head and some arms on a 171. WTF Bandai... this is a frontier valk. At least the isamu YF-19 was a closer cousin to the VF-19.
the 171 is not even close to a VF- 17.
Bandai should make a DX SDF-1 out of the Macross Quarter
-
5 hours ago, MKT said:
What's disappointing about the 1/28 scale is with all this talk about Robotech/Mospeada lore with the included sword for the dream episode.
There is not one container of "protoculture energy" canister attachment to insert. We just see the openings. they don't have any place for it but we got a dumb sword...
The coolest part of the show was the heist of the energy cells via balloons during yellow's concert.
I want some balloon attachments and energy cans to trade with Jonathan Wolf.
-
8 hours ago, TangledThorns said:
I took a week off to play BF6 the week after its released, lol.
i had a friend who was so drawn in by the beta he, didn't come out of his room the entire weekend. He said it was amazing.
-
Like the Isamu YF-29 Durandal Custom,
they should've marketed this as a 171 in M7 Diamond Force custom color.
-
I'm glad i ended up buying one of those high priced Yamato 17D that never went on sale from sabrina_skimpy from China.
-
1 minute ago, Chronocidal said:
"Holding up" doesn't do anything to fix the fundamental flaws in the engineering of this design. The legs are still one misguided transformation away from shattering, unless they've completely redesigned the mechanism, and I saw no change with that in the renewal.
i wonder if the shoulder triangles will crumble
-
38 minutes ago, treatment said:
lol
-
-
-
3 hours ago, lechuck said:
Some insight on the Toyrise Legioss Omega – interview with the people involved (Shinji Aramaki) creating it. Page three has the juicy bits for Mospeada fans.
QuoteThis story begins before I joined the production of the anime "Genesis Climber MOSPEADA." I was around 21 or 22 years old, and I dropped out of university in Okayama and moved to Tokyo for the first time, hoping to work in animation. By chance, I ended up doing outsourced work for Takara Tomy (then Takara). One of my jobs was the "Micro Change Series," the toys that inspired the now-world-famous "Transformers." These were transforming toys like "Camera Robot" and "Cassette Robot." I would go to Takara Tomy's (then Takara) headquarters once or twice a week, bring in B4-sized design drawings, and hold meetings with the people in charge to discuss them. Although I was an external designer, I was able to hear about the toy industry at the time, see prototypes, and experience the actual process of toy commercialization, which was a valuable experience for me.
very interesting.
Camera Robot and Cassette Robot... robot detailing of Soundwave, Rumble and Reflector on top of Mospeada.
-
20 hours ago, no3Ljm said:
METAL BUILD Force Impulse Gundam
『PREMIUM BANDAI FESTIVAL 2025』開催にあわせ、注目アイテムの「CLUB TAMASHII MEMBERS 優先販売」が実施決定! スカイステージ以上対象の優先先着販売と、全会員対象の抽選販売を予定。In conjunction with the "PREMIUM BANDAI FESTIVAL 2025," a "CLUB TAMASHII MEMBERS Priority Sales" of popular items will be held! Priority sales will be available on a first-come, first-served basis for Sky Stage and above, and a lottery sale will be open to all members.
Anyone getting Jesus Yamato killer?
This thing is so powerful it will destroy Freedom Gundam Concept 2.0
-
-
The Transformers Thread (licensed) Next
in Anime or Science Fiction
Posted · Edited by davidwhangchoi
@mikeszekely You know what really was disappointing with MP God Ginrai(Power Master Prime)?
They had an opportunity to make him as the artwork on the original box with the cab folded in the chest recessed to perfectly line up in the housing of the trailer. Instead, it's sticks out like the crappy g1 toy.
i want a power master prime!