Jump to content

BlackRose

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    77

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by BlackRose

  1. BlackRose
    All I want is a more balanced series like Frontier, 7, or the original. Delta is too much a Walkure commercial and not enough an actual story for me to get excited about it. I kind of want to see them go back and animate something like VF-X2 since that was so important to the story going forward.
  2. BlackRose
    Doesn't the high level of reflected light from the snow have something to do with that too? Snowblindness was a real problem for them and that's caused by reflected UV from snow. It wouldn't be the weirdest romance we've seen in fantasy. I don't completely disagree but I feel like the context matters more than the race. Like, if it's a community theater production they have to make do with whoever auditions. But in Hollywood they have a talent pool that's deep enough that doing it arbitrarily or because they're too lazy to cast a person who matches the author's intentions for the character it's wrong no matter what way it's going like casting ScarJo for Ghost in the Shell. If they're doing a reimagining of a story that changes the setting to a different location or time period it's more acceptable because the context of the story is different. Like if Bollywood decided to do a West Side Story reimagining set in Kashmir about an Indian man and Pakistani woman or something, that would be more OK becuase the context is completely different even if the broad strokes are the same. The Wiz is another good example since that one was set in more modern times with Dorothy being a girl from Harlem. It's way too early to tell if they're going to make major changes to The Little Mermaid. I'm a little worried we're looking at musical racial stereotyping in good old fashioned Disney tradition though.
  3. BlackRose
    It doesn't make a ton of sense biologically. Not that mermaids make sense biologically anyway. Melanin is natural insulation against UVB radiation which is why peoples from equatorial latitudes have more of it. Mermaids live on the ocean floor. In clear ocean water only 1% of light makes it down to 200 meters. There's no reason for mermaids to have a high level of melanin because the water is already protecting them from UVB radiation. Unless they live in shallow coastal waters less than 20m deep they should be like vampire levels of pale. Ariel's family live in a freaking underwater castle so they're probably deeper than that. As a black person I'm not sure I'm ok with this kind of casting decision. Like I get wanting minorities to have more representation in Hollywood but randomly making characters other ethnicities for no reason except representation feels more like a step back towards blaxploitation but with a better budget. At the time this story was written the Danish government was still kind of struggling with the idea that black people were people. They didn't even completely abolish slavery until 11 years after the story was first published. Don't even get me started on the problems that would cause if they decide to make the prince black too.
  4. BlackRose
    After 5 episodes I'm dropping Domestic Girlfriend. I'm all for drama in romance but this show doesn't have drama it has relentless misery. Natsuo is miserable because he's crushing on his teacher Hina who is in a relationship. Hina is miserable because she's the other woman to an unfaithful husband. Rui is miserable because Hina is miserable and she's socially awkward. Their parents are miserable because they don't understand why their kids are miserable. And now there's a suicidal girl too. This is daily soaps levels of messed up but without the camp it's just depressing. I have higher hopes for Magical Sempai. It seems like a fun little comedy after the first episode. Nobunaga Teacher's Young Bride and To The Abandoned Sacred Beasts sound like fun too. I put Servant x Service back into the lunchtime lineup as a pick me up after that depressing mess Domestic Girlfriend.
  5. BlackRose
    From the look of the photos of location shooting this show is a steaming pile of Do Not Want. If they wanted to do a story about a Starfleet admiral gone rogue why not Janeway? She's known for going rogue. Sometimes more than once in an episode.
  6. BlackRose
    Going to see this later today. I'm not too optimistic about enjoying it though since the eyes bug the crap out of me and the Rotten Tomatoes reviewer scores paint a pretty dismal picture. Overall it's got a 56 right now and among top critics a 33.
  7. BlackRose
    After the last one, I'm not going to bother going to the theater. I'll wait until it ends up on streaming. Kylo Ren isn't as badly written as Lucas's young Anakin but he's pretty close.
  8. BlackRose
    Neither is Kawamori. He's just the "series concept" guy when he's not drawing storyboards and designing robots.
  9. BlackRose
    Well yeah. That's setting the bar awfully low though isn't it? The season two premiere is the 2nd episode of Disco to actually feel like Star Trek. If they had started like I might actually not hate Burnham.
  10. BlackRose
    I'm planning to take a good look at Grimms Notes and The Quintessential Quintuplets over the weekend. Maybe Meiji Tokyo Renka if I can find the time. Shield Hero got off to a rough start but episode 2 was pretty good. Naofumi got his morality pet so he's not sulking 24/7 at least.
  11. BlackRose
    I feel a little cheated. All that buildup at the end of season one and the Enterprise and TOS aesthetic are gone in the space of one episode in season two. Now they're taking pointers from that awful Lost in Space movie.
  12. BlackRose
    I can't believe this book is still going. The art style changes so much because of all the tracing it feels like the comic book version of Movie 43.
  13. BlackRose
    That's a big risk they're taking. They're a good indie outfit so I hope it goes well for them. I kinda wonder if they're going to run into trouble since this is new territory. Nobody ever tried to make a full transforming toy of the Spartas before.
  14. BlackRose
    They're back into that flashback arc now that the previous edition never finished.
  15. BlackRose
    For my money it doesn't necessarily have to be mature storytelling as long as it's effective storytelling. If you can't get invested in the characters what's the point. Like for Delta it's hard to give a damn about Walkure or most of the other characters because we barely know anything about them.
  16. BlackRose
    Isn't that kinda like saying "Next to ebola, terminal lung cancer doesn't sound so bad anymore."? Everything about Titan's comic is horrible but the stuff that came before it wasn't better, just horrible in slightly different ways. If they can't go all in on hiring professionals to do a quality job why bother? This mess is just embarrassing to look at.
  17. BlackRose
    That'd be truth in television. Small rodents smell pretty bad. Rabbits are so stanky that they sell dietary additives to make them stink less. Porcupines are even worse and smell like oily garbage no matter what you do. A hedgehog the size of a person probably stinks like a compost pile. SEGA has been screwing that IP for decades. I don't know why they would even try after what happened to Super Mario.
  18. BlackRose
    Um I get the feeling you really epically overthought this. It's a toy commercial. It was made to sell plastic model kits from Revell's flop of a Transformers mockbuster. That's all there is to it. All the actual substance is from the original shows. You could probably get a good women's studies term paper out of the stupidly misogynistic writing in Southern Cross tho. It's not every day someone is ballsy enough to try to pass off a girl who only wants to be a housewife as a strong female character. Also that is a LOT of pretentious academic buzzwords. Like woah. It's been ages since college but aren't Freud and Jung both hopelessly outdated and unreliable psychological models? The content of the original shows The content of the original shows The content of the original shows Medically speaking there's no accounting for taste
  19. BlackRose
    Still no official news?
  20. BlackRose
    Maybe if you were judging them just on music you could say the Delta movie ranks above Plus, but if any other factor besides how likeable the main character is is in play then no way. To me it's more like FB2012 as a music video with hints of a story.
  21. BlackRose
    You're really struggling with the idea that stories need to have actual characters and a conflict the audience can be invested in on their behalf? That's the basics of storytelling. You can't have any characters or character development when your entire cast is unthinking mooks with no personality and half of them are literally faceless. There's no story to tell. It's just literally mindless violence.
  22. BlackRose
    RT never could get anywhere when it was trying to be original anyway. The less original it is the more RT fans like it. Some of them even say that this comic changes too much from the TV series and is bad for that reason instead of because its writing and art suck.
  23. BlackRose
    What's our ETA to the complaints about social justice casting like we had in Discovery? I wasn't impressed by STD season 1 so my hopes aren't high for the Picard series. Whenever Trek tries to push a social agenda in casting the writing takes a dive until they back off. Like can we get a black woman character who isn't either a strong black woman who don't need no man or a sassy black woman? I can't stand Michael Burnham because she's totally the embodiment of that one line Nichelle Nichols wouldn't say in Star Trek 6 about "would you let your daughter marry one". I guess they figured that Burnham's racism would fly under the radar better if it came from someone who was a minority.
  24. BlackRose
    Personally I think that HG's loss of faith in the series happened a lot earlier than that. Tommy Yune made a lot of promises to his bosses about what RTSC was gonna do to revitalize RT's prospects. It was supposed to legitimize RT as an original series in the industry's eyes. It was supposed to make RT into a popular mainstream anime title. It was supposed to bring in all kinds of new young fans who would buy all kinds of merch. It was supposed to make the world take notice of RT. When Tommy's baby didn't deliver on all of his promises and even people who were already RT fans mostly hated it, I think TPTB there at HG gave up on trying to do new stuff. They threw a mil at it and got no real result so why bother? The fans buy HG's bad Macross knockoff toys and posters no matter what. Everything they did since then was like a half-assed job to convince us that the lights were still on in the RT department. I don't think they really expected the Kickstarter to get funded. I think they thought they could just go "Well we tried!" when it failed and talk about how they're still working on it for years at cons without having to spend any money or actually do any work. I don't think even that failed tabletop game was meant to succeed and go past doing the Macross stuff. They picked a scale that made it impossible to do the next parts. Even this comic is totally obviously written to milk nostalgia for some quick money. They even set it up so they don't have to continue the story past the Macross part because this version is a stable Macross only time loop. I think the goal now is just to shake the fans down for as much cash as they can using nostalgia for Macross before the end of their license.
  25. BlackRose
    Thanks!
×
×
  • Create New...