Jump to content

noble_roar

Members
  • Posts

    1
  • Joined

  • Last visited

noble_roar's Achievements

Cannon Fodder

Cannon Fodder (1/15)

0

Reputation

  1. At least you disclaimered your sub-heading. That's right, Ohnogi is a loser in life and he married the next woman who came onto him because he was desperate, and that's why he was lying when he said he didn't have a hard-on for Sheryl. I bet you and Ohnogi gossiped together about his life over lunch? Oh wait. Do you even understand the ridiculousness of what you just wrote? And that's even before we get into the full meat of your post. It's always a mystery to me when someone takes one or two comments that briefly touched on a rejected love triangle from early production and spin a new fairy-tale on it. If you expect people to take this seriously, then please back it up with relevant sources. You failed to provide support for this profound Ohnogi revelation, and you failed to justify how this testifies against Ohnogi's writing, and all I see here is that you intend on Macross to follow the storyboard that came out of YOUR assumptions, and that didn't happen, you whined because he didn't fulfill your expectations the way you want him to. Look, it's increasingly difficult not to treat this as a butt-hurt Ranka post as you go on. The way I see it, Alto and Sheryl's relationship was being carefully handled, and it develops in a steady, almost slow pace. Whether it alludes to the creators' hesitant intentions on taking this further than what was already planned or not doesn't matter, they had a good number of episodes to build on a good, solid relationship. No one is forcing you to acknowledge it, but don't give me posts like 'Alto's sudden affinity with Sheryl' and base it on your pre-conceived notions about Alto and the girls and your incessant ranting about polar opposite personalities and try to pass it off as factual truths when it's not. Yes, there was that one scene, but you need to take into account that Sheryl was in his mother's bedroom, dressed in his mother's kimono and styled her hair in the same fashion. Alto's shocked reaction was understandable given the situation, but there was never a moment after that scene where the suggestion was ever brought up again. And no, it was not tacked on, it's clear you were only too willing to misinterpret the scene to use it for your Ohnogi tirade. Please be honest about it. It'll be a waste of time if we go round in circles over it. This isn't a piece on Ohnogi, I can't even respond to the rest of the post because it's nothing more than a long ship-ranting glossing over every detail about how bastard Ohnogi didn't make YOUR MACROSS happen. The post refused to make any distinction between the hard facts and the assumptions, some which were bordering on pure fanfiction, and I'm amazed that no one bothered to call you out on it. If there's one thing annoys me more than anything else, it's watching people obnoxiously pass off their own opinions as if they're substantial truths, without offering any references or sources to fall back to. Twisting the interviews and trying to pit creator against creator to aid stupid shipwars is NOT good tactics for a discussion, it's incredibly degrading to the staff who worked their efforts into the series for months. There will always be dissatisfied fans who offer constructive criticisms of the show, and it'll be good if we focus on the show's qualities and STICK with it, instead of going on about what YOU want to show to happen and cry over it when it DIDN'T, and adding a string of red herrings in hopes they go unnoticed.
×
×
  • Create New...